The "2 and 20" Rule: Understanding Fund Fees Before You Pay
Joining an investment fund can feel like a sensible shortcut: instead of picking every investment alone, money is pooled with other investors and someone else does the work. A recent podcast episode on Ali Alhamed’s channel takes up this idea under a direct title: “Want to enter an investment fund? Know the 2 and 20 rule before paying.” According to its description, the episode is meant for anyone who already has an income and a monthly surplus and wants to understand how to shorten the path to building assets, instead of gathering them alone over many long years. It is not for someone looking for quick profit. The description also notes that the numbers and percentages mentioned in the episode are illustrative examples and personal experiences, not a promise of future results. This article is a companion to that subject. It does not summarise the conversation; it explains what “2 and 20” means and what is worth understanding before paying any fund a fee.
Why funds charge fees at all
A fund gathers money from many people and invests it according to a stated strategy. In return, the people running it are paid. That is fair in principle: managing money takes time, research, staff and systems. The question is never whether there are fees, but how much they are, how they are calculated, and whether the investor understands them before committing.
Fees matter more than they first appear because they are taken every year, whatever the market does. Money paid out in fees is money that no longer stays invested, and over a long period that difference can become significant.
What “2 and 20” means
“2 and 20” is a well-known shorthand for a fee structure that has traditionally been associated with hedge funds and some private investment funds. It has two parts:
- A 2% management fee. Each year, the fund charges about 2% of the money it manages for the investor. This fee is usually charged whether the fund made money or lost money that year.
- A 20% performance fee. On top of that, the manager takes 20% of the profits the fund generates, under whatever conditions the fund’s documents set out.
Not every fund uses these numbers. Many charge less, some charge more, and many funds, such as most index funds, charge only a management fee with no performance fee at all. “2 and 20” is best understood as a reference point that helps an investor recognise the two kinds of fee and ask about each one.
How the numbers add up
A simple piece of arithmetic shows why this deserves attention. The figures below are purely for illustration, not a forecast of what any fund will do.
Suppose someone places 100,000 dirhams in a fund with a “2 and 20” structure. The management fee alone is about 2,000 dirhams a year. Now suppose, just to show the arithmetic, that in one year the investments grew by 10,000 dirhams before fees. The performance fee would be 20% of the profit, around 2,000 dirhams, depending on exactly how the fund calculates it. Together, the two fees could take roughly 4,000 of the 10,000 dirhams of growth, leaving the investor with around 6,000.
In a year when the fund falls in value, there may be no performance fee, but the management fee is usually still charged, so the loss is a little deeper. And because fees are taken every year, their effect compounds: money that leaves the fund cannot keep growing for the investor.
This is why fund documents contain terms worth reading slowly:
- Hurdle rate: a minimum level of return the fund must reach before any performance fee is charged.
- High-water mark: a rule that the manager earns no new performance fee until the fund has recovered any earlier losses and passed its previous peak.
- Other costs: entry or exit fees, administration costs, and rules on when money can be withdrawn.
Fund fees from a Shariah angle
For a Muslim investor, the fee is only part of the picture. Two structures are widely used in Islamic finance to organise the relationship between an investor and a manager:
- Wakala (agency): the manager acts as an agent and is paid a known, agreed fee for managing the money.
- Mudaraba (profit-sharing partnership): the investor provides the capital and the manager provides the work, and profit is shared in an agreed ratio. The manager does not guarantee the capital or a fixed profit, and a financial loss falls on the capital unless the manager was negligent or broke the agreed terms.
Many Islamic funds use one of these structures or combine elements of both, and the details are reviewed by the fund’s Shariah board. Scholars and Shariah boards do not agree on every detail of how fees may be structured, so anyone unsure about a particular arrangement should ask a qualified scholar.
Just as important is what the fund actually holds. The site’s FAQ makes the point plainly: some funds are halal and others are not, and the name alone is not sufficient. An investor should review the fund’s holdings, its underlying index, its investment structure, any use of derivatives, its Shariah screening methodology, its Shariah board and its purification process. A low fee does not make a fund suitable, and a fund with “Islamic” in its name still needs to be checked.
What to take away
Before paying any fund a fee, a few questions help turn a vague impression into a clear picture:
- What is the management fee, and what is it calculated on? Know the percentage and whether it is charged in losing years too.
- Is there a performance fee? If so, find out the percentage, how profit is measured, and whether there is a hurdle rate or a high-water mark.
- What other costs apply? Look for entry, exit and administration fees, and the rules for withdrawing money.
- What does the fund hold, and how is it screened? Review the holdings, the screening methodology, the Shariah board and the purification process.
- Does the fund’s timeline match the money’s purpose? Money needed soon, or an emergency fund, generally does not belong in an investment with long lock-ups.
None of this needs to be decided in a day. In the spirit of Ali’s teaching, little by little, don’t rush: understanding the cost of a fund before entering it is part of building wealth with a clear head.
For more on how funds and ETFs are assessed from a Shariah perspective, see the halal investing FAQ, and watch the full episode on Ali’s YouTube channel.
